Primi Italian Steakhouse

Note: The owner or a representative of this business has not yet completed the verification process

See more Terms of Service

4.3

( 8 reviews )

Seafood, Bar & Grill, Bakery

Closed 05:00 PM - 10:00 PM See Hours

999 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795, United States

+1 6315-269-779.0

Introducing Primi Italian Steakhouse, a renowned dining destination located at 999 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795. With a reputation for excellence, Primi Italian Steakhouse is a top choice for those seeking an unforgettable culinary experience. Offering an enticing menu filled with delectable dishes, including mouthwatering steaks and Italian specialties, this restaurant has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The inviting atmosphere, paired with exceptional service, sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. Primi Italian Steakhouse takes pride in providing a safe environment for guests, with strict adherence to Covid safety practices. From the moment you step in, you are welcomed by a team of dedicated staff members who prioritize your comfort and satisfaction. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for a night out, Primi Italian Steakhouse promises a dining experience that can't be beaten.

Amenities and More

Alcohol
Coffee
Accepts reservations
Credit cards
Small plates
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Outdoor seating
No-contact delivery
Cocktails
Vegetarian options
Bar on site
Fireplace
Valet parking
Solo dining
Comfort food
Trendy
Dinner reservations recommended

Reviews

4.3/5

8 reviews

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 stars

Randy king

March 22, 2024

Absolutely fantastic!! From start to finish a delightful meal. The special eggplant appetizer was so fresh and light! The lasagna was an explosion of flavors… not traditional but WOW!! The service was on point…Nicko is a wonderful server!

Yalonda ellis

March 22, 2024

My first visit to Primi was on a recent Saturday evening. I was warmly greeted by the valet parking attendant, and again by the staff at the entrance. We were celebrating a birthday and the service was efficient and accommodating. The highlight of my meal was a perfectly prepared bone in 20oz NY Strip with peppercorn sauce on the side. Halfway in, I told myself to stop, and to ask to have rest packaged to take home. It was so good that I finished it all at the table. Overall it was a very enjoyable experience.

Mike harvard

March 22, 2024

Came here with friends for date night/our friend's birthday and cannot say enough about how gorgeous the renovation looks! Our waitress was impeccable. She recommended the Lynchee martini for our friend who likes drinks on the sweeter side and a the vesper martini for myself. I don't eat steak and our server Jennifer recommended the Tuna and it was out of this world. It was my girlfriend's birthday and they brought out a cheesecake that was delicious along with our desert. What a nice touch. We had pasta as a starter (server recommendation) and a salad to start, everything was delicious. Food, ambiance and service was perfect, made our night! We will be coming back very soon!

Ashley gibson

March 22, 2024

Primi is recently renovated and the space is beautiful. The drinks and food are top notch! For appetizers we had the calamari, artichokes, arancini and grilled octopus for the table. Everything was delicious and perfectly cooked. Other highlights were the rib eye, tuna and shrimp for entrees. Danielle was our server and she is outstanding! I can’t wait to return for another meal.

Brooke bower

March 22, 2024

Finally tried this place after work. Great service and food. The grilled octopus is a must try. Super flavorful, perfectly cooked, and not rubbery as most restaurants tend to overcook octopus. The bartender, Alyssa, was very attentive and witty, and provided top notch service. She checked on my date and I frequently and kept the drinks coming. Atmosphere is very classy and the crowd was full of young to middle aged professionals. Great place to take a date. Def recommend 10/10!

Jenny yang

March 22, 2024

Fabulous! Great food. Amazing service.

Doug leese

March 22, 2024

First time here and wow. Such a great experience from start to finish. I highly recommend the bone in veal parm, old fashion, and sugar brownie with vanilla gelato and whiskey caramel pecan sauce.

David morgan (dsm)

March 22, 2024

Dined here on their reopening day, the food was mediocre at best, steak was absolutely disgusting, they put lemon ice cream on a chocolate brownie and it was disgusting. There are many better options for steakhouses in my opinion.